IMREF Network : International Midwifery Research and Education Network for Families in Vulnerable Circumstances
This e-magazine is a product of the International Midwifery Research and Education for Families in vulnerable circumstances (IMREF) network. This network consists of midwives, student midwives, teachers, and researchers. Together, they share knowledge, experiences, tools, and their networks with the aim to learn more about how to improve care for pregnant women and families who live in vulnerable circumstances. By working together and sharing knowledge and expertise, we can contribute to better quality of care.
The project from which the network emerged would not have been possible without the enormous efforts of all partners. It is of great added value to collaborate beyond the borders of your own country and system, and to work towards a common goal from there. We created a very inspiring network!
I hope that our network and this magazine will inspire (future) midwives, teachers, and researchers and that we can contribute to supporting them in improving care for vulnerable families across Europe.
Vulnerability among pregnant women is an important, broad, and complex theme in the everyday practice of midwives. Many risk factors, associated with adverse pregnancy outcomes, need to be monitored and often several health care professionals are involved. During the past years, several projects were initiated to improve the care for vulnerable pregnant women. Sharing the outcomes of these projects and sharing knowledge concerning vulnerability during pregnancy can contribute to improving care that is provided by midwives and might help to improve curricula for future midwives concerning this theme.
During this project, we developed the IMREF network. We developed a joint definition of vulnerability during pregnancy and we performed research concerning the organization of care and concerning existing best practices in the participating countries. Researchers and teachers from Rotterdam University of Applied Sciences (RUAS) initiated this project, which was partly funded by SiA RAAK (project number RAAK.MKB07.015). In this magazine, several midwives and project partners share their stories, what they have learned, and what they aim for in the future.
Midwives, midwifery teachers, researchers, and students, from seven cities participated in this project. Please place your cursor on the countries in order to see the participating organisations.
The project was divided into four work packages. These work packages allowed us to share knowledge and best practices during the project. Also, the work packages ensured the development of products that contribute to future exchange and to further dissemination.
Aim: prevent misconceptions, starting point of the project
A vulnerable pregnant woman is a woman who is threatened by physical, psychological, cognitive and/or social risk factors in combination with lack of adequate support and/or adequate coping skills.
6x challenges:
23x Best practices, such as:
Everyone can share their existing best practice concerning vulnerable pregnant women.
Midwife
Turku, Finland
My name is Tuula, and I am a midwife in Finland. I have nine years of experience working in the prenatal ward. I have worked with high risk pregnancies, and in the labour ward in a hospital in Turku. We deliver 4000 babies every year. Most midwives work in hospitals in my country. Midwives are graduated nurses as well, who can also work in maternity welfare clinics. Some midwives work as home delivery midwives, but this is rare in Finland.
Obesity is a problem in our country, and this is also a problem during pregnancy. Vulnerable pregnancies in Finland occur due to mental health issues, social problems, substance abuse, and obesity. We treat refugees on a daily basis, and face cultural and language barriers. We also face challenges related to pregnancies, such as preterm delivery and preeclampsia. I would say our pregnant women are mostly older. We don’t have the issue of teenage pregnancies. In many cities in Finland contraception is free, and our abortion rates are very low.
You may have heard of the baby box; the maternity package in Finland. It’s available to all expecting women visiting the maternity welfare clinic. It’s a huge box. It has baby clothes, diapers, a thermometer, small scissors, books, condoms for the new parents; things you will need in the first months with the baby. The cardboard box itself can be used as the baby’s first bed, as it has a little mattress inside.
One of the problems in Finland is that delivery hospitals are centralised. Women have to travel longer, and this has increased the number of deliveries on the road. The rise in induced labour is another challenge. We induce labour for several reasons, such as diabetes, or when the baby is overdue. The maternity welfare clinics are a great service, but the public health nurses working there don’t have to be midwives, they can be nurses. Nurses don’t recognize conditions in pregnancies as well as midwives, they don’t have the education and training of a midwife.
I got involved in this project through colleagues at the hospital where I work. They asked if someone would be interested, and I said yes. I would say it is good to be aware of experiences in different countries. It is good to bring in some best practices, also from abroad. For the future I hope we’ll develop guidelines for all European midwives to use. During this project I was inspired. It was lovely meeting midwives from abroad. I really hope that we can meet each other once more.
Midwife
Koszalin, Poland
I am Daria, I am a practising nurse in Poland. I was a paramedic for five years, and recently I completed my nursing studies. I work in the emergency department. It’s a place of instant action, there is not much time to talk to people and getting to know them. But in the case of vulnerable pregnant women it is different.
For example, sometimes a woman comes in with her husband, but she isn’t in a good situation with her husband. We need to take care of the woman, so in this case we have to explain the husband that he has to wait outside.
The main problem for vulnerable women that I meet is alcohol, aggression at home and unplanned pregnancies. And also a lack of money, sometimes, but this is gradually coming to an end.
In the program ‘Family 500+’ the government provides 500 zloty (100 euro) per month per child. A new program provides 300 zloty (60 euro) per month per child, starting when the child goes to school.
I wanted to get more knowledge and provide better care; that is why I studied to become a nurse. Nursing is more about prevention. It’s talking to people, getting to know them and help them with different situations. Our knowledge is important for people. We need to share our knowledge and explain it so that they get the help. That’s the biggest thing to do.
I got involved in this project when I was a nursing student. It was a great chance for me to learn about other topics. Especially topics that are not common in the emergency department. During the project we talked a lot about other country’s practices. It helps a lot. Through the project, we have a lot of new ideas on how to help vulnerable people. In our daily work we are so busy with our regular activities that we don’t think about vulnerability. Getting involved in a project like this makes us think from a different perspective, and this is really important.
I learned how different our problems are, and how in every country different issues arise. Also, I never saw cultural differences between the project members. I still like to work with all those women, I think it was great. I miss the activities we did together and I would love to be involved if a new opportunity came up.
Midwife
Antwerp, Belgium
I am an independent midwife in Antwerp, Belgium. My name is Fleur. It has been 15 years since I started my journey in midwifery.
I was an artist working in mixed media before getting involved in midwifery. It was with the birth of my own child that I started to feel interested in obstetrics. Motherhood and caring for babies intrigued me from an early age. That’s why I studied midwifery. In 2016 I stopped my full-time job as a midwife for the Belgium Government and started working as an independent midwife.
Originally I am from Holland, where I also worked as a midwife. The working environment for independent midwives is better in Holland; in Belgium it’s not optimal. Belgium has a very good healthcare system, but there is poor cooperation with most doctors, and the income is less. The range of duties for midwives in Belgium is broad. We provide information on birth control and contraceptives, we support women during menopause, and a lot more. In Belgium midwives also work as coaches to the parents. We guide them up to one year after birth.
In this project I learned that we all have been very creative in looking for solutions to guide vulnerable pregnant women. It’s always good to know that colleagues from abroad experience the same with vulnerable women. They inspired me because they were very creative with their ideas.
The plan was to get a definition for vulnerability in pregnancy, and this expectation was met. But we were eager to go a step further. We wanted to develop a flowchart for implementation as well. I hope this network will develop a flowchart for the implementation in the near future..
Maybe the most valuable element for me was to feel the good intentions of everyone, the drive to guide the vulnerable pregnant women in the best way. Because it’s not always easy. Sometimes you feel distressed or you feel unsafe, for example when you do a home visit and you know that something is going on. Talking about this and hearing the stories of international colleagues was really good. There was a good vibe during this project. I sensed the enormous strength and motivation we sometimes need and that we all have. It was good to hear from each other and yes, it made me proud.
Midwife
Milan, Italy
I work with women and babies after birth, in a hospital near Milan. I am Agnese, and I graduated in midwifery in 2018. I completed my studies in midwifery sciences two years later, in 2020.
The job of midwife is stimulating and challenging in our country. We have to make the women aware of the choices and possibilities they have. There are hospitals, private midwives and community midwives in Italy. Women can choose where to go. Both the private and community midwife can assist a woman till one year after child birth.
Here in my city, I encounter vulnerable women who don’t know the Italian language. Foreign women, women without support from their families, they are the vulnerable group here. They are also mostly young women with many children, so they don’t get the time to learn the language. They need a wider range of support.
I got involved with this project as a student. My professor, a researcher, invited me to join. It helped me, I learned a lot. I learned that vulnerability can be present in different social and economic situations. It can be dealing with addiction or dealing with a foreign language. Detecting vulnerability can be challenging, as it is different per situation.
In this project, midwives and students were there to study, to improve practices and to talk. It was the first time for me to talk about improving practices with other midwives and students. I learned about elements of community care that are not available in our country.
Vulnerability needs to be discussed more and more. It’s not something that can be resolved in a few talks.
I would like for this network to become wider. If we become a wider network with more people, we will have the power to take actions. That can be helpful for all women, all over the world.
Midwife
Ghent, Belgium
My name is Hilde De Grave. I am a senior midwife in Belgium. I have been working as a midwife for 36 years, in different settings.
Going abroad was the primary wish that led me to study nursing. Later I studied midwifery, and started practicing. I worked as a midwife in Rwanda. When I came to Belgium I started working as an independent midwife.
I also work at the Ghent University of Applied Sciences at the department of midwifery. My areas of specialization are primary healthcare, internationalization and intercultural aspects.
Vulnerability is a difficult aspect to catch and to put in a definition. Here in our city we come across vulnerable women almost daily. The poverty rate in some big cities in Belgium is close to 20%. Sometimes pregnant women don’t even have credit to make a phone call.
Government organizations working with vulnerable people do the same mind exercise on what vulnerability really is. Just last week we had a discussion with a gynecologist, who said that when someone has a monthly salary, they can’t be vulnerable. But there are so many aspects of life that can make us vulnerable. It’s not just financial. A young pregnant lady from Morocco, a pregnant teenager; their vulnerability may not be financial, but they may be socially isolated.
Three years ago we started a project for vulnerable pregnant ladies with the care model centering pregnancies. We propose the vulnerable pregnant women to come under this project. They have the possibility of meeting a group of 10 pregnant ladies. For us continuity of care is a challenge. In this care model we have monthly prenatal control and care. We try to work multidisciplinary. In prenatal workshops the women get the chance to meet psychotherapists, social workers, gynecologists all at the same time. We discuss every case together.
I was involved with the Rotterdam project because of our midwifery practice. They interviewed me three times and that’s how I got involved. I liked the brochure. The digital tool they developed for everybody to put their good practice into was really good.
It was really worthwhile. I think I saw the global scenario. But the project was too short, it was like an introduction. The aim of developing a curriculum was not reached. I think exchanging knowledge abroad gives you strength to work. Working with different tools and exchanging literature is so valuable and important. It’s not good to stay in your inner circle.
Now I wish the network to go more to the curriculum and develop a model which can be integrated in midwifery education.
Midwife
Lisbon, Portugal
I am Luisa Sotto-Mayor. I work as a midwife in a private birth and parenthood center.
I have been working as a teacher for the last 20 years and, every year, around 25 new nurse midwives finish their specialization and master's course. I consider my contribution to the training of these new midwives to be a very important part of my work today!
I was a community nurse for 14 years, before I specialized in midwifery. I have worked as a nurse-midwife in Portugal’s biggest maternity hospital for 12 years. I am a nurse specialized in maternal health and midwifery.
Being a nurse was and still is not a very good job in Portugal. We are considered to be the doctor’s aid.
In Portugal, girls as young as 13 or 14 years are allowed to have an abortion. There are no restrictions. Sometimes it gives them a special status among their friends, if they have had an abortion. No one tells them that having an abortion can damage someone for the rest of their life. In private hospitals there is another kind of vulnerable women, who don’t know they are vulnerable. They are submitted to a lot of interventions which are not needed. During this pandemic the main problem has been domestic violence. Some private clients are victims of domestic violence with mental problems.
In this project we had several meetings. That was very useful to build the relationship and make the networking stronger. The discussions worked as an eye opener for me. Situations that I would consider vulnerable, wouldn’t be considered vulnerable in for example the Netherlands. I should tell people who want to join the network in the future, that they will be surprised. You will learn a lot with the shared information.
Midwife
Dordrecht, Netherlands
I am Marlies, and I have my own midwifery practice with two colleagues in Dordrecht, a city near Rotterdam. We see pregnant women and we do the delivery, supervising the childbirth of around 315 babies every year. We also do home visits after birth, visiting mother and child. I am a midwife for 24 years now.
In the Netherlands most midwives work by themselves, not in hospitals. So I work in my own clinic as an independent midwife. Pregnant women in my country can choose between delivery in the hospital or at home. Midwives make the risk selection for when home delivery is no longer safe and the mother has to go to hospital. The mother can at any time choose to go to hospital as well. I go with them to hospital.
Vulnerability exists in different forms. It can be domestic violence, abuse, or being a refugee. I think in our country being in a difficult social and economic situation is the big problem. In the last two years the problems of refugees have increased.
We see a lot of vulnerable pregnant women with several problems: teenage pregnancies, social isolation and loneliness, excessive smoking. Every woman with her own problems needs a different type of care. The most important thing is to gain their trust; because if you don’t have their trust you only do the regular checkups and you might miss the vulnerability. It’s important to ask a vulnerable woman what she needs. I think home visits are really important. Because when you see the situation at home you see much more than the women coming to the clinic.
I knew Hanneke Torij, the initator of the project, before the project started. They approached me and asked me to join as I am a practicing midwife. That’s how I got involved. The most interesting thing about this project is that I felt I am not alone in this situation and we learn a lot from other people. It was so nice to hear from other colleagues how they provide care to these women, but also the problems you encounter as a care provider, your limitations or the search for good help. In the project I saw we have the same intrinsic motivation regarding the problems we handle.
Sometimes we think we are doing the best in our fields, but it’s really good to know how others are dealing with similar situations. Through this network, we can develop a curriculum for the universities in future.
Researcher
Rotterdam, the Netherlands
I am Jantine and I am a Researcher at the Research Centre Innovations in Care, of the Rotterdam University of Applied Sciences.
When we start inviting people for the grand application, everyone was so excited to join the project. It was nice, there was really good vibe. It is really interesting to see different problems in different countries, and also the similarities, in the care for vulnerable pregnant women. Midwives and researchers from different countries were working together, and students as well.
In the Netherlands, midwives usually work in independent practices, where in other countries midwives usually work in hospitals. Most pregnant women first go to an independent midwife, and will only go to hospital if there are complications. The independent practices are nice, because they are in your own community.
I really liked the live meetings of the project because that was really good way to exchange information and to hear how midwifery care is organized in different countries.
Discussing the definition of vulnerable pregnancy was a really nice starting point of the project. Because there is no international definition of vulnerable pregnant women and it’s good to have a project definition of vulnerability. It led to really nice discussions. Because who is vulnerable and what is vulnerability?
The expectation was to exchange knowledge and best practices, and we really achieved that goal. The cooperation of the different project members was really, really great. This has exceeded our expectations. We didn’t know all the participants when we started, we all live in different time zones, and we thought it would be difficult to communicate with everyone. But everyone was very dedicated to the project and the communication went really well. Everyone was very enthusiastic, and everyone spent many hours in the project and the cooperation.
I would like to continue the cooperation with all the different countries and all the different members of the network. And it would be great to expand the network.
Project Director
Rotterdam, the Netherlands
I have always been committed to the best start for newborns and their parents. Families who live in vulnerable circumstances often lack adequate access to health care and more often have poor health skills. How can we ensure that every woman, every child, and every family, can receive the best possible care and support before and during pregnancy, childbirth, and early childhood? And how can we best equip (future) professionals?
In my research program we focus on these questions. We try to develop new knowledge and tools that contribute to better care and support to vulnerable families. I have met many colleagues during the past years, also internationally, who are actually working with the same questions.
During discussions and conversations internationally, two things kept coming up. The first is that midwives need training and support to be able to provide adequate care to vulnerable pregnant women and their families. This also needs to be embedded in midwifery curricula. The second is that many professionals throughout Europe struggle with the same theme. That is why we started this network: To cooperate and to exchange knowledge and best practices so that we can learn from each other. With the aim to supporting (future) mothers and families in the best possible way, and, at the same time, empower midwives, students, teachers, and researchers throughout Europe.
Students ask other questions than professionals, because they see things from another perspective and often for the first time. Midwives bring their knowledge and experience from daily practice and based on their experiences from practice. Teachers, who have ideas and experience concerning the embedding of this theme within the curricula, bring their knowledge and perspectives related to education. And researchers, who develop knowledge and tools, and struggle with how to involve vulnerable families into their research, how to measure the effects of interventions, and how to generalize research results, bring the scientific perspective into the network.
During this project, we succeeded in bringing these students, teachers, midwives, and researchers together. We worked in, and discussed about, these issues, we exchanged best practices, and we initiated the IMREF network.
Something that works well in Lisbon, Portugal, isn’t necessarily a best practice in Turku, Finland. But at the same time, we can learn from each other’s practices and use elements of best practices in a different context.
If you involve professionals from all over Europe, when a midwife from Turku talks to a teacher from Milan, or a midwifery student from Lisbon meets a researcher from Antwerp, then you are really challenged and inspired to look at this theme from another perspective. This is very inspiring and opens doors to new solutions in improving the quality of midwifery care.
When we look at the communities in all the participating cities in our network in Europe, the key is to be involved in a community, and work together with families and (future) mothers.
When you do that, you can really contribute to a healthy start for newborn babies and mothers in vulnerable situations. In every life, a healthy start in this world is very important. There is a relation between a good, healthy start in life and the chance of having a good future. Midwives play an important role in providing a healthy start for all families.
Within our network, we have succeeded in bringing together knowledge and experience from midwifery education, research, and practice throughout Europe. For the future, we want to perpetuate and expand the network. We welcome midwives, students, teachers, and researchers throughout Europe to join us!
June 2022
Rotterdam University of Applied Sciences
Taskforce for Applied Research SIA | (NWO)
Rotterdam University of Applied Sciences
Hanneke Torij
Jantine van Rijckevorsel
Hilde De Grave
Tuula Villa
Daria Kuleń-Sławińska
Fleur Schenk
Agnese Lecis
Luisa Sotto-Mayor
Marlies van Pijkeren
Irene Bartelds
Syed Wadud
Poroma Shome
Mahmud Haider
Shaon Bahadur
RedOrange Media and Communications
IMREF Network: International Midwifery Research and Education Network for Families in Vulnerable Circumstances.